This post was last updated on October 17th, 2023
Were you wiggling your thumbs thinking about the best websites to buy used board games online? Welcome, you are in the right place now.
I know very well that buying new board games can sometimes be quite expensive, but fret not! You can find excellent options online at a fraction of the price by purchasing used (or even better nearly used) games.
In this article, I’ll explore the top ten websites where you can buy used board games online, ensuring you get the best deal and expand your collection without emptying your wallet.
So, whether you’re a casual gamer or a dedicated collector, these sites will hopefully meet your needs and will help you to find a variety of fantastic games to enjoy in the comfort of your own home.
MENZIONA boardgameprices.com
This post may contain affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, I will get a commission at no extra cost to you. See our Affiliate Disclosure.
Top 10 Online Websites
- BoardGameGeek Marketplace
- BoardGameGeek Auctions
- Gamenerdz
- Noble Knight Games
- Amazon
- Ebay
- Reddit’s Boardgameexchange
- Cardhaus
- Facebook Marketplace
- Craigslist
- Bonus website: Zatu Games
Board Game Geek Marketplace
The first website on my list is our beloved Board Game Geek aka BGG.
No need for presentations here, BGG is very well known and unless you live on Mars you’ll know this website already.
What you may not know is that BGG has its own marketplace where people from all over the world post their board games with the intention of selling them.
Here you’ll find a wide selection of used board games from a dedicated community of enthusiasts.
You just need to create an account (it’s free) and start browsing through the available listings.
You may even discover some rare or out-of-print gems!
Link: boardgamegeek/market
Board Game Geek Auctions
The second website in this list could only be another feature on Board Game Geek.
This time I’m talking about Board Game Geek Auctions.
This feature offers the thrill of bidding on coveted titles, potentially allowing you to secure fantastic deals.
As multiple listings on the website could become very cluttered in a short time, I suggest you subscribe to MetaList for GeekList auctions to participate in exciting and time-sensitive sales events.
If you subscribe to this page, you will receive a notification every time a new auction is published.
Link: boardgamegeek/auction
Gamenerdz
For those who don’t know it, Gamenerdz is an online retailer based in Texas that’s quite famous for selling products at very competitive prices.
This store is amazing for when you want to buy new board games but it’s also perfect if you’re looking to buy used ones too.
For this last category, they have a specific section on their website called “Ding & Dent“.
Although there may be some cosmetic imperfections, these games are functional and the damages are clearly listed.
They also offer competitive prices, which makes it an attractive option for bargain hunters.
If only their selection of used board games was wider!
Game Nerdz offers free shipping on orders of $75 or more.
Link: Gamenerdz.com
Noble Knight Games
Noble Knight Games is a website that specializes in selling both new and used board games, as well as other types of games and gaming supplies.
They have a large selection of used games, that ranges from well-loved classics to the latest releases, and their website allows you to search for games by title, publisher, or other criteria.
Noble Knight Games also has a reputation for offering fair prices and accurately describing the condition of their used games, so it can be a good option for those looking to buy used board games online.
They use some criteria to describe the state of their games:
- [SW] Shrink Wrapped. Still in the original factory shrink wrap, with condition visible through shrink noted.
- [Mint] Perfect. Brand new.
- [NM] Near Mint. Like new with only the slightest wear. Close to perfect, and very collectable.
- [EX] Excellent. Lightly used, but almost like new.
- [VG] Very Good. Used. May have medium-sized creases. Complete and very useable.
- [Fair] Very well used, but complete and useable.
Thanks to this clear rating system you’ll always know what you’re about to get.
Plus, if you’re looking to sell your board games, you can get a free quote from them at nobleknight.com/Buy-Sell-Trade
Noble Knight Games offers free shipping on orders of $149 or more.
Link: NobleKnightGames.com
Amazon
Amazon isn’t only a place for new games, but also a treasure trove for used board games. Filter your searches for ‘used’ items to find used games at a good price.
The site offers a wide selection of titles and many sellers offering used games at competitive prices, with the advantage of having reliable shipping and buyer protection.
However, as with eBay, it is important to be cautious when buying from individual sellers and to read the product description and any reviews carefully before making a purchase.
Your purchase is covered by Amazon’s return policy, so if you receive a damaged or incomplete game, you can return it for a refund or replacement; also, if you are a Prime member, you can often receive free shipping on eligible products, which can be a great way to save on shipping costs.
Link: Amazon.com
Ebay
Ebay is a global marketplace offering a large collection of used board games.
It can be a good place to buy used board games, as there are many listings available and good deals can often be found.
However, it’s important to be cautious when buying from individual sellers, as the condition of the game may not be described accurately and there is a risk of receiving a damaged or incomplete game.
It’s a good idea to carefully read the seller’s description and look at the photos before buying and only buy from sellers with a good feedback score.
Once you are satisfied with the photos and the seller’s reputation, do a quick search on the price to make sure it is in line with the market price to avoid pulling extra money out of your pocket.
Link: Ebay.com
Reddit’s Boardgameexchange
The r/boardgameexchange is a subreddit dedicated to buying, selling, and trading board games. It can be a good place to find used board games at a reasonable price, as well as to connect with other board game enthusiasts and potentially trade games you no longer want for ones that you’re interested in.
Each post is titled following a formatting rule which makes it easier and faster to read:
[Location] location details of the seller/buyer.
[Tag] FS – FT – WTB these tags represent For Sale, For Trade, and Want to Buy.
[Games] the games you’re selling or looking to trade.
As with any online marketplace, it’s important to be cautious and to carefully read product descriptions and reviews before making a purchase.
I’m not discovering the hot water, but it’s a good idea to only buy from sellers with a good reputation and to use a secure payment method such as PayPal to protect your purchase.
Here you can find some highly suggested posts to read before diving into the subreddit.
Link: Reddit.com/r/boardgameexchange
Cardhaus
Cardhaus is an online retailer that specializes in selling board games, card games, and gaming accessories.
They offer a wide selection of new games from popular publishers such as Fantasy Flight Games, Asmodee, and Days of Wonder, as well as lesser-known indie titles.
There’s a section on their website called “dinged and dented” where they post used board games at competitive prices.
The amount of board games isn’t huge but you may find some gems if you’re lucky.
Cardhaus offers free shipping on domestic orders over $99.
Link: Cardhaus
Facebook Marketplace
Facebook Marketplace can be a good place to buy used board games, as there are often many listings available and you can often find good deals.
Additionally, buying from local sellers can be convenient as you can arrange to pick up the game in person, which can save you money on shipping costs.
When buying using this platform be sure to only buy from trusted sellers and to use a secure payment method such as PayPal to protect your purchase.
In general, always exercise caution when arranging meet-ups and transactions.
Link: Facebook Marketplace
Craigslist
Finally, Craigslist is a popular classifieds website for buying and selling items locally. You can often find used board games at attractive prices, listed by individuals in your area.
Remember to follow the site’s guidelines and prioritise your safety when meeting and exchanging money.
Link: Craiglist
Bonus website: Zatu Games
If you live in the UK and you’re looking to find a good website to buy used board games online, Zatu Games could be a great option.
They have an “outlet” section on their website where you can find some amazing deals.
At the moment of writing these lines, there’s a copy of A Grade Wingspan listed at £26.49 which let you save around 50% of the retail price.
Zatu Games has a rating system based on 2 terms:
[A grade] products may arrive with or without cellophane and may have minor cosmetic damage to the box.
[B grade] products may arrive with or without cellophane and may have sustained varying levels of cosmetic damage to the box. This may include tears, dents and crushing in some cases.
For each purchase made on Zatu Games, you’ll collect a certain amount of Victory Points, which can be accumulated and then used to get a discount on future purchases.
You can even earn points when you buy used board games! Let me go grab that copy of Wingspan, bye!
Link: Zatu Games
Extra Tip for Buyers
I found a very interesting website that offers a price comparison tool that allows users to find the best prices for board games across multiple online retailers, as well as showing you the current deals of the day across each store.
This website is called Boardgameatlas, be sure to bookmark it and visit it from time to time as you might find some pretty good deals thanks to it!
